We have investigated sidecars in several ways (different orange liquors, lemon vs ReaLemon, the impact of aging lemon juice), but this time we wanted to compare more types of lemon juices side by side.
While we love sidecars and have eliminated ReaLemon as a viable option, there are still a number of different lemon juices available. For this run we are not going to use the typical go-to product at the Primary Testing Facility, True Lime, as 1. it’s lime, and 2. being a powder it can be distinctive if full dissolution is not achieved.
Thus, for this taste test we used the following:
- fresh-squeezed Sunkist lemon (suspected Lisbon variety)
- fresh-squeezed Sunkist Meyer lemon
- lemon-grenade (lemon shaped bottle by Concord Foods) lemon juice from concentrate
- bottled Nellie & Joe’s Key West lemon juice from concentrate
Fortunately we were mixing these with brandy, as the lemon juices were pretty distinctive by themselves:
Our standard, charm-based, double blind taste testing procedures (described here) were used.
|1||Fresh Lemon||unanimous first choice, drink had a coarse yellow foam and tart, or “assertive”, lemon flavors – but not in an unpleasant sense.|
|tie||Key West||drink separated into a cloudy suspension and clear liquid, somewhat Tang-like and slightly harsh.|
|tie||Meyer Lemon||less foam than the fresh lemon, and also noticeably sweeter and more orangey.|
|4||Lemon-shaped bottle||everyone agreed this was their least favorite; drink had a distinctly different white foam, and was the most “lemon-y” but more harsh than our favorite.|
Every taster was able to correctly identify the juice in each drink before the results were revealed, and we all agreed on the first and last places. There were some disagreements on the middle two, mostly due to how people responded to odd flavors in the Keywest versus the non-agressive Meyer, which created an unbalanced drink. There were some interesting physical differences, with the behavior of the Keywest lemon juice being pretty strange (see below), and each juice produced a distinctive foam texture/color.